Play your (battle)cards right
Ask a few people at your company why customers should choose you over a competitor, and you’ll probably get a different answer from each. Sales remembers the objection that sank last week’s deal, marketing talks positioning, product points to features, and customer success knows which promises hold up.
Everyone is holding useful cards. The challenge is knowing which ones a seller should play.
That’s the job of a battlecard. A good one brings together how to position against the competition, which questions to ask, which differences matter, and how to handle likely pushback, all in a format sellers can use in the middle of a deal.
Read the table
Start with what’s happening in sales conversations. Which competitors keep coming up? Where do buyers hesitate? Which objections stall a promising deal? Win/loss reviews, call recordings, and sellers themselves are all good sources.
What matters most internally isn’t always what matters to buyers. A product team might be proud of a technical advantage buyers rarely ask about, while sellers need a clearer case for why switching from an existing solution is worth the effort. Sometimes the toughest competitor is the status quo. The card should reflect those conversations.
Look before you play
Familiar objections aren’t always what they seem. Take price. When a buyer says a competitor’s quote came in lower, they might prefer the competitor for another reason, see little difference between the products, or question whether yours is worth the premium. A canned line about long-term value treats all three the same, so a better battlecard helps the seller find out what’s behind the objection.
Buyer: Their quote came in lower.
Seller: If the prices were the same, which would you choose?
If they’d still choose the competitor, there’s another preference worth exploring. If they’re unsure, they may not see a meaningful difference yet. And if they’d choose you, the conversation can turn to whether the premium is justified or the budget simply won’t stretch.
Same objection, very different conversations. A good battlecard helps sellers recognize the difference and respond accordingly.
Play the cards that count
Figuring out what’s behind an objection is half the battle. The other half is having the right information to address it.
- Comparing products? Lead with a differentiator that matters to this buyer.
- Worried about implementation? Share a story from a company like theirs.
- Questioning the investment? Bring credible ROI numbers and show the assumptions.
Be honest about where a competitor has the edge, too. A seller who concedes a fair point is more believable on the next one.
Discard the rest
Sales, marketing, product, and customer success each have something they want on the card, and every piece makes sense on its own. Put it all together, though, and the seller has to dig for what they need.
The real work is connecting those perspectives, testing which arguments hold up, and deciding what earns a place on the card. Sometimes that means one well-placed question instead of five, or one credible example instead of a page of claims. It can also mean tailoring a card to a specific industry, so sellers have the right customer stories and talking points at hand.
Format helps, too. A single card might be enough for quick reference mid-call, while a deck organized by competitor or industry lets sellers flip straight to the guidance they need.
A great battlecard feels simple because the hard decisions have already been made. Make those calls before the call, and the seller can spend it listening to the buyer.
Got a competitor who keeps showing up in your pipeline? Deal us in.